Integrating sustainable Islamic social finance: An Analytical Network Process using the Benefit Opportunity Cost Risk (ANP BOCR) framework: The case of Indonesia

The utilization of Islamic social finance instruments is far behind what is expected. To realize its full potential, Islamic social finance instruments must be integrated. This study examined solutions and priority strategies for integrating sustainable Islamic social finance that could be implemented in the short and long term using the Benefit, Opportunity, Cost, and Risk (BOCR) framework, which includes six aspects: Governance, sustainable financing, institutional aspect, human resources, regulations, and supporting technology. This qualitative research employed the Analytic Network Process (ANP) method using the benefit, opportunity, cost, and risk analysis. The data were obtained mainly through focus group discussions and in-depth interviews with respondents among academics, practitioners, associations, regulators, and community leaders. The respondents were selected for their expertise and experience in the selected topic. The data were processed using the Microsoft Excel and Super Decision software. There are several findings worth considering from the analysis. First, the highest priority in integrating Islamic social finance aspects are human resources (0.97), regulation (0.86), and technology (0.76). Second, based on the short- and long-term analysis, financial integration through sustainable financing (0.01 and 1.44, respectively) and improving human resource quality through certification and training (0.01 and 1.56, respectively) is a priority solution and strategy to integrate sustainable Islamic social finance. Meanwhile, according to expert judgments, integrating national data (0.24) and optimizing technology use (0.18) are priority solutions and strategies. The findings emphasize the critical role of improving human resource quality to utilize technology, with experts identifying a national data integration as the most critical solution. As a result, relevant stakeholders are concerned about technology management training for Islamic philanthropic managers, with the goal of maximizing the potential of technology’s growing role and adoption.

Informed consent for participation was obtained from respondents who participated in the survey. The respondents who participated in the survey were asked to read the ethical statement (there is no compensation for responding nor is there any known risk.
To ensure that all information will remain confidential, please do not include your name.
Participation is strictly voluntary and you may refuse to participate at any time) and proceed only if they agree. No data was collected from anyone under 16  If the data are held or will be held in a public repository, include URLs, accession numbers or DOIs. If this information will only be available after acceptance, indicate this by ticking the box below. For example: All XXX files are available from the XXX database (accession number(s) XXX, XXX.).
• If the data are all contained within the manuscript and/or Supporting Information files, enter the following: All relevant data are within the manuscript and its Supporting Information files.
• If neither of these applies but you are able to provide details of access elsewhere, with or without limitations, please do so. For example: Data cannot be shared publicly because of [XXX]. Data are available from the XXX Institutional Data Access / Ethics Committee (contact via XXX) for researchers who meet the criteria for access to confidential data.
The data underlying the results presented in the study are available from (include the name of the third party • Data cannot be shared publicly because of data integrity and security. Data are available from the Universitas Airlangga Institutional Data Access / Ethics Committee (contact via email ekis@feb.unair.ac.id) for researchers who meet the criteria for access to confidential data. and contact information or URL). This text is appropriate if the data are owned by a third party and authors do not have permission to share the data.

• * typeset
Additional data availability information: Tick here if your circumstances are not covered by the questions above and you need the journal's help to make your data available.

Introduction
Islamic Social finance (ISF), which includes zakat, infaq, sadaqah, waqf, and Islamic microfinance, is critical to promoting a long-term economic development [1][2][3]. Islamic social finance has a vital role in solving the problem of poverty [3][4][5][6] , income inequality [7], global education [8,9], health access [10], and various other socio-economic problems. The role of Islamic social finance instruments is not only in the majority Muslim countries, but also in minority Muslim countries, such as the role of zakat in providing supportive programs for the poor in Singapore [11] , the role of Islamic social finance to support economic resilience in the UK [12], and the role of zakat in creating prosperity in Germany, France, and Croatia [13].
Islamic social finance has also shown a great promise in addressing socioeconomic issues during the Covid-19 pandemic. The pandemic has had a significant impact, especially in the economic field [14]. The economic implications of Covid-19, particularly in Indonesia [15,16], include increasing unemployment and underemployment rates, declining income levels, economic contraction, slow and uneven recovery process across sectors, including the health, economic, and education sectors. This is due to the limited sources of funding owned by the state. The government has prepared a reserve budget of USD 5.3 billion and a budget for the National Economic Recovery program of USD 37.3 billion. The funding was used for the health sector (USD 1.0 billion), social protection (USD 2.5 billion), and support for micro, small, and medium enterprises (USD 1.8 billion) [17]. The sources of funds were derived from debt, government bonds, Sukuk, and foreign debt. The Ministry of Finance [18] released the funding components of Covid-19 originating from market financing, bilateral and multilateral debts, private placement, financing from over budget balance (SAL), and the use of government endowment funds. These components certainly have limits to meet the growing needs of handling Covid-19. Consequently, the government needs to find alternative sources of funding. Islamic social finance with a great potential can be utilized to lessen the burden of funding and accelerate the recovery from the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic.
Indonesia, as a Muslim majority country, has a high potential for Islamic social finance. The potential for collecting zakat funds in Indonesia in 2020 was USD 23 billion [19], cash waqf was USD 12.6 billion per year, and the overall value of waqf land is USD 140 billion [18]. However, the collection of zakat and waqf funds is still far from its full potential. The zakat collection in Indonesia in 2019 was only USD 0.7 billion [19], while the cash waqf funds collected were only USD 0.2 billion [18]. One of the reasons for the vast gap between the realization and potential of ISF is a lack of optimal governance [20].
Furthermore, the management of ISF faces several problems, including the lack of technology utilization in its management [20], the lack of ability and competence of managers, and the lack of synergy between stakeholders [20,21], and lack of trust and public literacy [20,22]. Based on a survey conducted by BAZNAS (Zakat Government Institution), nationally, the level of zakat literacy is at 66.78 %, which is in the middle category. Despite the country having the largest Muslim population, the literacy level for several provinces in Indonesia is still in the low category, with a score below 50 %. This means that literacy is not at an advanced stage, of which this includes knowledge about the existence and functions of ISF institutions, regulations, impacts, programs, and digital payments [23].
The governance of ISF includes aspects of collection, management, distribution, and utilization of social funds. The issues of ISF governance can be categorized into six aspects consisting of Human Resources (HR), Unsupported Policies and Regulations, Technology, Sustainable Financing, Governance, and Institutional Aspect [20,[24][25][26]. Problems in the HR aspect include the lack of ability and motivation of human resources to develop both managers and recipients of Islamic social funds [20]. In addition, Islamic philanthropic institutions are dominated by employees who are not from the background of Islamic Economics and Zakat Waqf management, causing the low productivity to manage ZISWAF. In addition, the low literacy related to Islamic social funds needs to be addressed by policymakers [27].
Unsupported policies and regulations become issues from the regulatory aspect [20]. First, zakat is still a voluntary act [20] and there is no sanction for those who do not carry out zakat [28]. Further, the laws that govern ISF are separated as zakat is governed by Law No. 23 of 2011, whereas waqf is governed by Law No. 41 of 2004. In addition, the infrastructure required for management needed to be addressed, particularly in the field of technology [20]. This becomes an issue that deserves consideration [29]. Many institutions do not have the required financial capacity to purchase the infrastructure needed to support technology-based governance.
Problems related to the sustainability aspects of the ISF program are of concern to IRTI [29], Pitchay et al. [24], and Sukmana [26]. Based on the findings in the field, most empowerment programs using Islamic social funds do not consider sustainability aspects and seem to end when the program ends, so that the primary goal of empowerment, namely, the transformation of mustahiq into muzakki, or mauquf ' alaihi into wakif, cannot be achieved. In addition, in the aspect of governance, Islamic social fund instruments are still partially managed. These instruments have not been integrated with the State's fiscal policy [30]. This is because Indonesia is based on "Pancasila", not a country based on Islamic law, of which its population consists of various beliefs and religions. There could be a sense of injustice if the government only regulates ands takes money from Muslims to help government finances. On the institutional aspect, there is a lack of coordination and synergy between stakeholders [20]. The lack of public trust in Islamic social finance managers [25] needs to be an essential concern for policymakers. To overcome these problems, the solution that can be done is to formulate the integration of the Islamic social finance sector and establish a sustainable management ecosystem.
The purpose of this research was to develop a strategy for the short-and long-term integration of ISF and to determine the best way to achieve that goal. This study was carried out in Indonesia, a country with a high potential for accumulating ISF . In practice, however, the ISF are only partially managed and have not been fully integrated. Raimi et al. [31], Jouti [32], and Shalleh et al. [33] conducted research on ISF integration. Previous research formulated the integration of ISF without emphasizing sustainability, and thus, the sustainability aspect in integrating Islamic social funds is highlighted in this research. Furthermore, previous studies employed a qualitative approach through case studies, literature reviews, content and thematic analysis, and a quantitative approach through Structural Equation Modeling (SEM). There has been no research that incorporates ISF that employ the two-level ANP method. The analysis of Benefit, Opportunity, Cost, and Risk (BOCR) to build the ANP framework is what makes this research unique. Several factors influenced the decision to use this method. To begin, the ANP method was used to determine the best integration in the long-term management of ISF. Second, the analysis of the benefits, opportunities, costs, and risks of each aspect was to produce findings that can be implemented in the short and long term. Third, this study identified priority solutions and strategies for achieving long-term ISF integration using the ANP BOCR method.
The findings show that the financing integration model is a priority solution in the short and long term. This demonstrates that the ISF serves several functions: Consumptive zakat is used to provide emergency assistance in the short term, productive zakat and benevolence funds are used to support economic recovery in the medium term, and waqf or sukuk are used to build long-term resilience. Furthermore, the findings of this study highlight the importance of improving the quality of HR managers through a technology-based certification and training (particularly for data analysis, e-marketing and big database management) as the best shortand long-term strategy for implementing Islamic social finance in a sustainable manner.
The findings of this study are critical for several reasons. First, solutions and strategies for the integration of sustainable ISF are expected to solve various problems of managing different instruments of ISF, resulting in the formation of a sustainable ISF ecosystem. Second, the findings of this study serve as a resource for the ISF institutions in developing long-term strategic plans. Third, the results can provide a broader impact on people's well-being. Fourth, in the context of the Covid-19 pandemic, the findings can provide an overview of strategic policy steps and guidelines for seeking alternative funding sources by leveraging the potential of sustainable ISF.

Literature review The concept of Islamic social finance and its instruments
Islamic social finance is a financial system that includes traditional and contemporary ISF instruments [32,[34][35][36]. Traditional ISF can be divided into two types: Philanthropy and cooperation. Zakat, infaq, sadaqah, and waqf are traditional ISF instruments based on philanthropy, while qard and kafalah are based on cooperation. Furthermore, Islamic microfinance can be categorized as contemporary ISF. Islamic social finance contributes to the third sector of the economy by assisting in creating more economic activities and reducing unemployment and poverty [37]. Several previous studies have revealed the differences in the instruments used in Islamic social finance as shown in Table 1. Most of the previous research mentions that the instruments for ISF include zakat, infaq, sadaqah, and waqf [32,38,39]. Therefore, in this study, ISFinstruments refer to zakat, infaq, al and waqf, and Islamic microfinance.
Each of these instruments has different roles and functions but shares the same objective in achieving prosperity [32]. The first instrument is zakat, a mandatory economic instrument for every Muslim [40,41]. Zakat serves as a means for distributing wealth in the society [42] from the rich to the poor to achieve socio-economic justice, increase economic growth, and reduce inequality [43]. The second instrument is infaq and sadaqah, which are the voluntary gifts by capable people to seek the pleasure of Allah [44], significantly to help the needy. Zakat, infaq, and sadaqah are economic instruments that support economic growth by increasing the purchasing power of the needy [3,31].
As a third instrument, waqf is a social fund that plays a vital role in the Islamic framework. An asset owner donates and dedicates movable or immovable assets for the benefit of the community in perpetuity or impermanence. Waqf can be used to provide a variety of free community services, such as the construction of mosques, hospitals and healthcare centers, madrasas, education centers, and libraries [26]. Waqf is a vital tool in the Islamic economic system used to meet the needs of the poorest communities and promote community economic growth [26]. Furthermore, waqf, zakat, and sadaqah are instruments capable of acting as the national income and transfer payments used for redistributive purposes in an Islamic economy [6].
Islamic microfinance is the fourth instrument of ISF. Islamic microfinance serves two purposes: Social and commercial. As a social institution, it manages zakat, infaq, sadaqah, and waqf in accordance with the Syariah. On the other hand, as a commercial institution, it conducts businesses and provides financing for economic development. Islamic microfinance focuses on economic development through capital assistance and the empowerment of the marginal community with no access to capital to improve their well-being [45].

Sustainability of Islamic social finance
Sustainability refers to the capacity to operate over a long period and continuously [46]. Sustainable growth has become a global development goal in both government and nongovernmental organizations [47]. There are two paradigms in sustainability, namely, the institutionalist and welfarist [48]. The institutionalist paradigm considers that financial self-sufficiency is the key to achieving sustainability. Thus, a person can be said to be sustainable if he or she achieves financial independence [48]. In contrast, the welfarist paradigm considers that social functions in poverty alleviation are more important in achieving sustainability. Both paradigms are essential in the context of ISF. Financial self-sufficiency refers to an institution's ability to fund its operations independently, while also benefiting others. On the other hand, the main goals of ISF are poverty alleviation and its reachability [49][50][51]. Three factors contribute to the sustainability of Islamic social finance. First, the collection's sustainability is linked to the fact that funds will always be collected from the community. To ensure the longterm viability of funds supply, all information about zakat and its administration must be transparent and easily accessible to the public [52]. Second, institutional sustainability is linked to the institution's ability and availability to carry out operational tasks [48]. Third, the sustainability of distribution is linked to how the Islamic social finance institution performs its social and intermediary functions to improve welfare and achieve broader benefits [50].
In practice, the empowerment programs of ISF institutions have not been able to transform the poor into prosperous. Furthermore, many of these programs come to an end after a certain period and do not track whether the poor have truly become self-sufficient and prosperous. Several factors contribute to the unsustainable nature of ISF institutions' empowerment projects [20]. To begin, massive sums of money are required to provide effective and optimal empowerment. Second, qualified human resources with leadership qualities are needed [53]. Third, the beneficiary's desire and ability to develop and change into muzakki or munfiq are required [3,54].

Issues with Islamic social finance integration
In order to achieve optimal management, ISF must overcome several challenges. A lack of motivation among beneficiaries to develop, a lack of synergy and coordination among stakeholders, a lack of human resources capabilities and quantity to manages Islamic social finance, a lack of ability to optimize technology, regulations that are still voluntary, and a lack of awareness and trust of muzakki in Islamic social finance institutions are among the problems encountered by Islamic social finance [20,[24][25][26]55]. Further, the ISF instruments are still partially (separatedly) managed, which is demonstrated by several points. First, according to the 2017-2022 Indonesian Zakat Architecture, zakat management is supported by regulations but remains a voluntary instrument, not an obligatory instrument [20]. Second, ISF instruments are governed by different regulations and laws. The management of zakat is regulated in Law no. 23 of 2011, while the management of waqf is regulated in Law no. 41 of 2004. Further, ISF instruments are managed by various institutions (government, corporate and community organizations) [56] of which there exist differences in the rights, obligations, and interests of different institutions. Fourth, the regulators of zakat and waqf are not the same. The National Amil Zakat Agency (BAZNAS) regulates zakat, while the Indonesian Waqf Board (BWI) is the waqf management regulator. However, BAZNAS and BWI are eventually accountable to the Minister of Religion Affairs. Based on these challenges, the integration of ISF must be carried out.

Integration model of Islamic social finance
Integration refers to the process of blending into a single unit, thus, integration in ISF combines funds management, institutions, governance, functions, etc. According to Balassa [57], integration offers various advantages. First, integration allows for the mobility of production elements, which has a positive impact on enhancing welfare. Second, integration reduces costs, resulting in an increase in output. Third, integration promotes job specialization. Fourth, integration creates a welfare through policy harmonization. Fifth, integration can increase technology adoption. Furthermore, integration has a favorable impact on the socio-economic aspects of the community, including: (1) Improving sustainability performance [58], (2) enhancing economic growth [59], and (3) improving socio-economic fairness [2].
Raimi et al. [31] integrated corporate social responsibility, zakat, and waqf into the faith-based model to reduce poverty, promote business development, and strengthen the economy of Muslim-majority communities. Hassanain [60] conducted a literature review on microfinance, waqf, and zakat to develop an integration model. Haneef et al. [45] used the Structural Equation Model (SEM) analysis to examine the significant influence between differencct aspects of Islamic social finance that include waqf, takaful, human resource management, and financing. Pitchay et al. [24] conducted a literature review to develop a cooperative-waqf model. Further, using the thematic analysis, Ambrose et al. [61] developed a waqf financing model for public goods and mixed public goods in Malaysia, where the proceeds of waqf investment can be used to fund 11 items of government spending.
A research that specifically discusses the sustainability of the ISF model was carried out by Jouti [32], which focuses on creating an ISF ecosystem, and by Shalleh et al. [33] which focuses on the integration of waqf-based takaful for flood victims in Malaysia. This study developed the previous research by building an integration model between ISF instruments with an emphasis on sustainability aspects using the two-level ANP method.

Research method and analysis approach
The Analytical Network Process (ANP) method was used in this qualitative study, along with the analysis of Benefit, Opportunity, Cost, and Risk (BOCR). This two-level ANP method has the characteristics of mathematically examined conditions and inputs obtained based on several constructs, allowing it to aid the decision-making from various options and complex data [62]. The ANP method approach was chosen because ISF include various instruments, each with its own set of characteristics and issues, both tangible and intangible. In this study, the ANP approach was the best choice for producing strategic decisions [63]. Meanwhile, the BOCR analysis was selected for a variety of reasons, to begin, every decision has both positive and negative consequences, which must be considered when determining priority decisions. Second, the BOCR approach was used to make decisions that can be implemented in the short and long terms. The ANP BOCR method prioritizes solutions and strategies to develop a sustainable ISF integration model. The ANP method of research has three phases, which are depicted in Fig 1 [64].

Figure 1. ANP BOCR Research Stage
Source: Ascarya [64] First, the decomposition phase sought to construct and validate the ANP model through focus group discussions and in-depth interviews with experts in ISF among academics, practitioners, associations, regulators, and community leaders. A literature review was conducted as part of this study to strengthen the ANP model that was developed. A literature review analysis was used to collect problems, solutions, and strategies discovered and analyzed by previous researchers to integrate sustainable ISF. In addition, the literature review analysis was used to validate the findings from the focus groups discussion and in-depth interviews.
Three Focus Group Discussions (FGDs) were held. The first and second FGDs were held with experts to identify aspects, solutions, and strategies for integrating sustainable ISF and identify benefits, opportunities, costs, and risks to determine the short-term and long-term analyses. The model developed through FGD 1 and 2 was then strengthened through in-depth interviews and literature reviews. Following that, the third FGD validated the constructed ANP model. The second was the pairwise comparison phase to design a questionnaire in the form of a pairwise comparison to determine and analyze aspects, solutions, and priority strategies in integrating sustainable ISF. The questionnaire that the respondents had answered were used for the next phase. The third was the data analysis phase, which aimed to calculate the priority value of each aspect, solution, and strategy formulated using the Microsoft Excel and Super Decision software. The use of the ANP method with the BOCR approach made it possible to produce realistic and net values. The net value/additive negative describes alternative options that are more profitable or ideal to be prioritized in the long term, while realistic/multiplicative value represents more favorable outcomes for short-term decisions [63,65]. According to Saaty and Vargas [63] there are several steps to synthesize each priority option from each criterion where: Net Value/additive negative = bB+oO-cC-rR (1) Realistic/multiplicative = (BxO)/(CxR) (2) B or b stands for Benefit, O or o stand for Opportunity, C or c stands for cost, R or r stands for Risk. After the analysis phase, the next step was to validate the results with various ISF experts to strengthen the integration model that will be built.

Data and research samples
The data used were primary data obtained through focus groups, in-depth interviews, and ANP questionnaires filled out by the respondents. The data sources gathered were from 13 experts among academics, practitioners, associations, regulators, and community leaders. In ANP research, the number of respondents is not a critical requirement for research validation [66] but their expertise is. Each expert completed the questionnaire consciously and in a mentally healthy state. The participants were required to fill in a specific consent form beforehand to ensure that they were not subject to any pressure from any party to participate in the interviews. The research team guaranteed the confidentiality of the experts' data and responses and is fully responsible for all applicable laws. Applicable laws will account for the disclosure of confidential data and experts' responses.
In terms of research ethics, this research followed the rules and ethics of research conduct and writing coordinated by the Institute for Research and Community Service (LPPM), Universitas Airlangga and those mandated by law. It is also explained in the Airlangga University Chancellor's Regulation Number 34 of 2019 concerning the Rules of Conduct clause 16 (b) that researchers must be honest, objective, and adhere to all aspects of the research process and may not falsify or manipulate data or research results, as well as clause 16 (f) that researchers must respect and appreciate the object of research, whether in the form of humans or animals, both living and dead, or parts/fragments of the object of research. In addition, this research was supervised by the Center for Research and Publications (3P) within the Faculty of Economics and Business Universitas Airlangga, which functions as an ethics committee according to the Dean Decree Number 88/UN3.1.4/2020.
The purposive sampling technique aims to select respondents according to the criteria required in the ANP method. For this study, the selected respondents must have the following criteria: (1) Respondents are experts in the field of ISF among academics, practitioners, associations, regulators, and community leaders, (2) have more than two journal publications in the field of ISF for academic representatives, and (3) for representatives of regulator, practitioners, and associations, they should hold an important position and bear a great responsibility in the management of ISF in their respective institutions. The research team contacted the prospective (representative) respondents by phone and email before conducting the interviews to inquire about their willingness to complete the questionnaire. There were two options for completing the questionnaire: Online or offline. For the respondents who opted to complete the questionnaire offline, the research team attended to them, while adhering to a strict health protocol, by still maintaining a safe distance and wearing a mask. For respondents who opted to fill out questionnaires via teleconference zoom, they were accompanied by three team members with each job desk either as a moderator, a note-taker, or a backup. The list of respondents in this study is shown in Table 2. The questionnaire of the study is in the form of a pairwise comparison of the benefits, opportunities, costs, and risks of related aspects in integrating sustainable ISF. Governance, sustainable financing, institutions, regulations, technology, and human resources are among the issues at stake in integrating the instruments of ISF. The questionnaire also comprises various solutions and strategies to achieve the research objectives. The pairwise comparison assessment in the questionnaire is rated on a scale of 1-9, where 1 (one) means not important/needed/influential and 9 (nine) means absolutely important/needed/influential.

Result
This study aimed to integrate sustainable ISF by building solutions and priority strategies in the short and long term. Before developing solutions and strategies, identification of important aspects was carried out to provide a comprehensive analysis of the most appropriate priority solutions and strategies in integrating sustainable ISF.

Priority aspect
Human resources, regulation, technology, sustainable financing, governance, and institutions are six aspects related to the integration of sustainable ISF, according to the FGD and in-depth interviews. Table 3 shows the aspects with the highest priority based on the ANP data processing. The data processing results show that human resource is the highest priority aspect in ISF institutions, with a value of 0.97181. Human resource refers to all people/staff/employees who participate in the management of ISF [20]. With a value of 0.8689, the regulation comes in as the second priority. Regulations are all rules put in place to provide legal guidance and support for the management and development of ISF [67]. With a value of 0.7682, the third priority aspect is the use of technology, while sustainable financing comes in the following priority order with a value of 0.7645. Sustainable funding is associated with business development and achieving financial independence using Islamic social funds [68]. Governance is the fifth priority aspect with a value of 0.7152. The collection, distribution, and utilization process in ISF are governed by transparency, accountability, responsibility, independence, and fairness [69]. The institutional aspect comes as the least priority, with a score of 0.6767. The institutional aspect relates to the structure and coordination system. In Indonesia, ISF institutions can take the form of government and private legal entities [70]. For zakat management, the legal entity can take in the form of Amil Zakat Institution (LAZ) and the National Amil Zakat Agency (BAZNAS), while Nazir is the legal entity for the management of waqf.

Priority solution in integrating sustainable Islamic social finance
There are eight solutions to integrate sustainable ISF based on the findings of the focus group, in-depth interviews, and literature review. The first (SL.1) is a financial integration in providing funding to beneficiaries through the distribution of zakat, waqf, and Islamic microfinance based on the beneficiaries' economic circumstances and capabilities. The second step (SL.2) is integrating ISF with state fiscal instruments, which is supported by existing regulations. Integrating Islamic social finance with the fiscal policy can be accomplished by making zakat a tax credit or tax deduction. The third (SL.3) is an integration through non-formal coordination between ISF institutions. The Islamic social finance institutions may establish joint coordinations to conduct empowerment programs, while prioritizing the work specialization of each institution. The fourth solution (SL.4) is an integration among Islamic social finance institutions based on capacity building and role division. This type of integration includes vertical and horizontal integrations [70]. The vertical integration is achieved through a collaboration between ISF institutions and the government. The government collaborates by providing a database of people who are eligible to receive Islamic social finance funds. The government also provides rules and guidance for the management of ISF. Meanwhile, a horizontal integration is conducted between ISF management institutions, where different institutions collaborate to carry out joint social programs [32]. In addition, a horizontal integration is also carried out with academics and associations for future management development of the ISF [20]. Some organizations concentrate on the health sector, while others concentrate on economic empowerment and education. As a result, combining institutions based on their specialization may be the best option for achieving the research objective. The fifth (SL.5) is establishing an integrated national data center for all ISF instruments; the data that must be integrated include financial statements, donor funds, beneficiary data, and other relevant information. The sixth (SL.6) includes an integration based on regional clusters with a solid authority. This integration may concentrate on integrating Islamic social finance institutions into geographical groups. The seventh solution (SL.7) incorporates integrating ISF through the passage of new laws and regulations. Each instrument of ISF, currently, has its own set of rules and regulations. The eighth solution (SL.8) is an integration based on ISF management clusters, such as zakat Amils joining other zakat institutions and waqf manager joining other waqf institutions. Table 4 shows the ANP result of solution and the order of priority solutions in the short term, long term, and based on experts' agreement The formulated solution was then processed using the ANP BOCR to determine the priority order of solutions. Short term solution considers the marginal cost of the benefits obtained. On the contrary, in the long term, the priority is achieved when the total number of benefits and opportunities are obtained after reducing the total cost and risk [63,65]. On the other hand, an expert judgment does not consider the benefits, opportunity, cost, and risk aspects of each solution formulated in this study. Table 5 summarizes the results of data processing. According to the data processing results, the first and second priorities in the short and longterm are in the same order. The solutions that will be implemented first and foremost in the short and long term are financial integration in providing funding to beneficiaries and integration of Islamic social finance with the state fiscal policy. According to expert judgment, integrating national data centers is the highest priority solution, with financial integration in providing funding to beneficiaries coming in second.

Priority strategies in integrating sustainable Islamic social finance
There are nine strategies to integrate sustainable ISF based on the findings of the FGD, indepth interviews, and literature review.  Table 6, which displays the short-term, long-term priority solutions, and expert judgment. After developing the solution, a strategy must be developed. Strategies are employed to aid in the achievement of solutions, and thus, the integration of ISF will be realized. The strategies are summarized in Table 7. The results show that the short and long-term strategies are in the same order. Improving the quality of human resources, establishing real-time database integration and reporting, and optimizing the use of digital technology, become the priority strategies.
However, the expert judgment considers the optimization use of digital technology to be the priority strategy.

Priority solution in developing a sustainable Islamic social finance integration model
Financial integration in providing financing to beneficiaries is a high-priority solution that can be implemented in the short and long term. Further, this solution is very consistent with the sustainability paradigm, where the funding provided will broaden the range of benefits, and ultimately creates financial independence for the beneficiaries, as stated by Haneef et al. [45], Azganin et al. [71], Thaker et al. [72], and Widiastuti et al. [20]. Sari et al. [73] show that by distributing zakat, the time taken by the poor to exit poverty is faster (3.3 years) than without zakat (6.6 years). In addition, a study conducted by Widiastuti et al. [3] analyzed financing programs carried out by the ISF institutions, including Yatim Mandiri, Dompet Dhuafa, Inisiatif Zakat Indonesia, Nurul Hayat, YDSF, and Dompet Amanah Umat, and found that they have a significant impact on increasing the welfare of the poor. The distribution aspect, particularly productive distribution, holds the key to success in ISF integration in transforming the poor into the capables [69]. A financial integration through ISF instruments, such as zakat and waqf, will increase production factors. In this case, financing will be more effective due to an increase in the amount of funds obtained by the poor to achieve welfare. This is consistent with the economic integration theory discussed by Balassa [57]. This also supports Sanyinna and Omar [74] claim that Islamic financing benefits small businesses by maximizing Islamic social financial instruments (zakat, infaq, sadaqah, and waqf) as the best strategy for improving the recipients' quality of life. The financing provided through integrating Islamic social finance instruments has a cheap cost of the fund, and thus, it ensures the beneficiaries' welfare. Furthermore, the integration of financing demonstrates that Islamic social fund instruments serve multiple purposes: Consumptive zakat is used to provide an emergency assistance in the short term, while productive zakat and benevolence funds are used to support economic recovery in the medium term, and waqf or Sukuk are used to build long-term resilience. The financial integration of Islamic social finance instruments has also occurred in several institutions, although only on a micro-scale. Several institutions in Indonesia have worked to integrate zakat and waqf funds. Dompet Dhuafa, for example, integrated zakat and waqf funds when constructing an Integrated Health Home (Hospital). Cash Waqfs are used to build infrastructure on waqf land, whereas zakat funds provide free health care to the poor. Further, recently, Dompet Dhuafa, BAZNAS, and BWI have collaborated to integrate zakat and waqf, the newly established MoU, to collaborate on social projects. This priority, however, differs from expert opinion, which emphasizes the importance of integrating nationally centralized data, such as database on donors, beneficiaries, and financial reports. According to Afriadi and Sanrego [54] and Hudaefi et al. [75] the formation of national-centered data is critical for optimizing the integration and management of ISF . The integration of beneficiary-related information is crucial for detecting data on beneficiary development and preventing overlapping distributions. Since ISF are still managed in a fragmented manner (partially), no single platform currently integrates the data from all instruments of ISF in Indonesia. As the latest development, a data integration platform has been established in the zakat sector. BAZNAS, an Indonesian zakat institution and regulator, released SIMBA (BAZNAS Information Management System), an integrated platform for zakat database management from all BAZNAS and LAZNAS across Indonesia. This platform only integrates the data from national zakat collections. As a result, establishing a central platform capable of integrating data on all Islamic social financial instruments is critical.
Financial integration and integration of national data centers are interrelated. This is so since funding distribution necessitates specific data to ensure the long-term viability of the funds provided. Data integration is needed to reduce the potential risk and realize the collection of distributed financings so that the supply of funds will be guaranteed. Further, the integration of beneficiary data is needed to ensure the depth of the reach of benefits and the creation of financial independence, and thus, sustainability will be achieved. On another side, financial integration remains a short-and long-term priority because it is directly related to the primary goal of Islamic social finance, which is to create prosperity by improving the business and economic capacity of beneficiaries. As one of the priority solutions in this research, the regulator must provide a legal environment to accommodate all changes and developments in the management of Islamic social finance. First, the government must revise the law to accommodate the rapid growth of Islamic social finance instruments [76]. Second, the government must socialize the revised laws and regulations to all stakeholders, and make the law more socially acceptable [20,77]. Third, encourage ISF management institutions to implement the law by offering rewards or incentives that the Institution can use, such as free training and accompaniment [20].

Strategic priorities in developing a sustainable Islamic social finance integration model
According to expert judgments, the strategy with the highest priority is optimizing the use of digital technology. This in line with Thaker et al. [78], Usman et al. [79], Berakon et al. [80], Nor et al. [81], and Widiastuti et al. [20], all of which emphasize the importance of using technology in managing the instrument of ISF. First, technology for creating a centralized database linked to the government and ISF supervisors is one example of a technology that can be used [20]. This strategy is also linked to the immediate solution, which is the consolidation of national data centers for all Islamic social and financial instruments. To become effective and efficient, data integration necessitates the creation of a sophisticated web-based platform that all stakeholders can access. Second, technological advancements in supervision and monitoring [20]. Third, technology in the marketing component to aid in the collection of target achievement [82,83]. Fourth, technology to generate real-time management reports and make them available to the public [20].
However, in terms of short-term and long-term priorities, optimizing the use of technology has slipped to third place. Experts consider improving the quality of human resources to be the most important aspect, both in the short and long term. The importance of enhancing the capability of human resources goes in line with Karami et al. [84], Hidayatullah and Priantina [21], Ali et al. [55], and Widiastuti et al. [20]. The difference in priorities between expert judgments and short/long term orientations occurs because of technology investment, which is considered a long-term investment, necessitates a significant funding source, which some zakat institutions may not afford [20]. Optimizing the use of technology, which requires a large amount of investment, is a challenge for Islamic social finance institutions, particularly in Indonesia. This is due to the fact that the operational costs incurred by ISF institutions are determined by the amount of funds that can be raised. Meanwhile, there is a significant gap between the realization and potential of ISF. As a result, institutions prefer to improve competencies and capabilities of human resources, relevant to their respective fields of work compared to improving technological features. This is also consistent with the aspects of BOCR addressed in this study. The cost of optimizing technology use is 0.0537, higher than the cost of improving the quality of human resources, which is around 0.0466. Costs associated with technology investments include acquiring digital channels, website management, social media, purchase of computers, and maintenance cost.
Furthermore, when determining priority strategies in the short and long term, experts also consider the risks exposed. The risk of optimizing the use of technology is high (0.0632), with the benefits obtained are also higher (0.0555). Meanwhile, the threat from the institution's strategy to improve the quality of human resources is lower at 0.0459. Cybercrime is one of the risks of optimizing the use of technology in ISF [85]. To mitigate this risk, competent human resources in their field are required. Implementing technology without qualified human resources will result in sub-optimal management. This is consistent with the findings of Widiastuti et al. [20] that a limited number of human resources is capable of optimizing the use of advanced technology, particularly in those newly established institutions. Therefore, experts place qualified human resources as the prioritized strategy to mitigate risks, not only risks associated with technology application, but all risks associated with the integration of sustainable Islamic social finance.
Optimizing the use of technology and improving human resource quality can be done concurrently as stated by Widiastuti et al. [20] that highlights the importance of improving the quality of zakat management resources, particularly in the technological aspect, by emphasizing technology intensification (by developing Amils' ability to use technology) and extensification (by increasing the number of Amils who master technology). Improving the quality of human resources is the foundation for the long-term integration of ISF, while technology facilitates an optimal ISF management.
Finally, in order to integrate sustainable ISF, stakeholders must prioritize solutions and strategies, by considering the benefits, opportunities, costs, and risks (BOCR) of each priority solution and strategy. Improving the quality of human resources and optimizing the use of digital technology are two strategies that must be implemented immediately. Based on the short-and long-term analysis and expert consensus, the two strategies are given the highest priority.

Managerial relevancy
This study has several implications for stakeholders. The findings of this study emphasize solutions and priority strategies for integrating ISF, with Islamic social finance institutions playing a critical role in providing certification and training to improve the quality of human resources. Each training activity and accreditation must be given in accordance with the employee's field of work. Technology optimization, such as big data management, data security, e-marketing, and others, are examples of certification and training that must be provided. Human resource quality must be directed to obtain management and technical skills. Managers are encouraged to have managerial skills, such as making strategic decisions, forecasting, and imposing rewards and punishments. Staff are encouraged to learn technical skills, such as collection program operation, mustahik guidance, reporting, and administration.
The government, as a regulator, must assist Islamic social finance institutions in providing facilities or infrastructure to improve the quality of human resource managers, such as free training and certification for managers. Further, no law or regulation has required ISF managers to have standardized or specific competencies. As a result, one form of input for the revision of the law and regulation requires all ISF managers to have specific competencies in managing Islamic social finance institutions so that these institutions can be managed more professionally.
This study also emphasizes the significance of financial integration and data integration on the national scale. Associations involved in Islamic social finance can use the research findings to establish strategic planning on integrating ISF instruments. From an academic standpoint, the results of this study develop the previous studies on the integration of the ISF model, which were conducted without using specific mathematical methods. This study used a systematic approach to create an ideal integration model that can be of priorities both in the short and long term, while also taking the aspect of BOCR into account.

Conclusion
This research used the ANP BOCR to develop priority solutions and strategies to integrate Islamic social finance based on expert agreement, short-term and long-term analysis. The aspect of human resources, regulation, and technology use become the highest aspect to be considered in achieving the research objective. Priority solutions in the short and long term have the same order of priorities. Financial integration in providing funding to beneficiaries and integration with the state fiscal policy is the first and second priority solution. Meanwhile, integration through a non-formal coordination between institutions is the third priority solution in the long term. Besides, integrating national data centers has been the third priority solution for a long term and the highest solution based on expert judgments. In essence, the resulting priority solutions relate to priority aspects include financing, regulation, and technology.
As a strategy, improving the quality of human resources, establishing real-time information through database integration and reporting, and optimizing digital technology are three priority strategies that can be implemented in the short and long term. Furthermore, the experts mentioned the need for coordination and synergy between stakeholders in integrating sustainable Islamic social finance. To successfully incorporate Islamic social finance and ensure sustainability, stakeholders are encouraged to implement the research results (solutions and strategies). There is an integration of Islamic social finance into commercial enterprises b. There is an MoU between BAZNAS and BWI to integrate zakat and waqf c. Many previous studies support the governance of zakat and waqf d. There are already standards for zakat and waqf management e. Some programs increase the motivation of donors to channel funds to Islamic social, financial institutions f. Every Islamic social finance institution has a supervisor so that the institution's operations run according to the plans and applicable rules g. The existence of a sharia supervisory board makes decisions more appropriate and following sharia rules h. Strengthening SDGs for Islamic social finance institutions will provide clear and measurable goals i. There are financial reporting standards for Islamic social financial institutions j. National data integration k. Increased effectiveness and efficiency in the use of operational funds 2. The following are several benefits from the aspect of sustainable financing in supporting the creation of the integration of Islamic Social Finance; how important are the benefits below in supporting the creation of the integration of Islamic Social Finance? a. The availability of cheap funds sourced from zakat, infaq, alms, waqf will make it easier for MSMEs to get financing b. Financing carried out at BMT includes social and financial functions commercial to increase the competitiveness of BMT c. There are many contracts in financing (qard, ijarah, mudharabah, etc.) that can reach a wider target recipient.

Abstract
The utilization of Islamic social finance instruments is far behind what is expected. To realize its full potential, Islamic social finance instruments must be integrated. This study examined solutions and priority strategies for integrating sustainable Islamic social finance that could be implemented in the short and long term using the Benefit, Opportunity, Cost, and Risk (BOCR) framework, which includes six aspects: Governance, sustainable financing, institutional aspect, human resources, regulations, and supporting technology. This qualitative research employed the Analytic Network Process (ANP) method using the benefit, opportunity, cost, and risk analysis. The data were obtained mainly through focus group discussions and in-depth interviews with respondents among academics, practitioners, associations, regulators, and community leaders. The respondents were selected for their expertise and experience in the selected topic. The data were processed using the Microsoft Excel and Super Decision software. There are several findings worth considering from the analysis. First, the highest priority in integrating Islamic social finance aspects are human resources (0.97), regulation (0.86), and technology (0.76). Second, based on the short-and long-term analysis, financial integration through sustainable financing (0.01 and 1.44, respectively) and improving human resource quality through certification and training (0.01 and 1.56, respectively) is a priority solution and strategy to integrate sustainable Islamic social finance. Meanwhile, according to expert judgments, integrating national data (0.24) and optimizing technology use (0.18) are priority solutions and strategies. The findings emphasize the critical role of improving human resource quality to utilize technology, with experts identifying a national data integration as the most critical solution. As a result, relevant stakeholders are concerned about technology management training for Islamic philanthropic managers, with the goal of maximizing the potential of technology's growing role and adoption. Purposeutilization sfsfdsfGThis research analyzes solutions and priority strategies for integrating sustainable Islamic Social Finance that could be implemented in the short and long term by analyzing it through the Benefit, Opportunity, Cost, and Risk (BOCR) framework, which comprises of six aspects: Governance, Sustainable Financing, philanthropic Institutions, Human Resources, Regulations, and Technology.
Design/methodology/approach -This qualitative research employeds the Analytic Network Process (ANP) method using the bBenefit, oOpportunity, cCost, and rRisk analysis. The dData were obtained    mainly through fFfocus gGgroup dDdiscussions and in-depth interviews with experts fromamong academics, practitioners, associations, regulators, and community leaders. weforthe The data wereis processed with using the Microsoft Eexcel and Super Decision software. from the analysisin the-, respectively, respectivelysfaresiesrolea 'edfor BOCR(BOCR) Consequently, the solutions and strategies developed will be more integrative and sustainable in the future for the advancement of Islamic sSocial fFinance.
Findings -There are several findings worth considering. First, the highest priority integrating Islamic social finance aspects are human resources (0.97), regulation (0.86), and technology (0.76). Second, based on a short and long-term analysis, financial integration through sustainable financing (0.01 and 1.44) and improving human resource quality through certification and training (0.01 and 1.56) is a priority solution and strategy to integrate sustainable Islamic Social Finance. Meanwhile, according to expert judgments, integrating national data (0.24) and optimizing technology use (0.18) is a priority solution and strategy.
Practical implication -The findings emphasize the critical importance of improving the quality of technology-based human resources, with experts identifying national data integration as the most critical solution. As a result, relevant stakeholders are concerned about technology management training for Islamic philanthropic managers, with the goal of maximizing the potential of technology's growing role and adoption.
Originality/value -This study develops solutions and strategies for short and long-term Islamic social finance integration by identifying the benefit, opportunity, cost, and risk of six related aspects. As a result, the solutions and strategies developed will be more integrative and sustainable for the betterment of Islamic Social Finance in the near future.
Keywords: Financial Sustainability, Integration, Sustainable Islamic Social Finance, ANP BOCR, Priority Strategy

IntroductionNTRODUCTION
Islamic social SsSocial finance fFinance (ISF), which includes zakat, infaq, sadaqah, waqf, and Islamic microfinance, is critical to promoting a long-term economic development [1][2][3].  [7], global education [8,9], health access [10] , and various other socio-economic problems. The role of Islamic social finance instruments is not only in the majority Muslim countries, but also in minority Muslim countries, such as the role of zakat in providing supportive programs for the poor in Singapore [11] , the role of Islamic social finance into support economic resilience in the UK [12], and the role of zakat in creating prosperity in Germany, France, and Croatia [13].
Islamic social finance has also shown a great promise in addressing socioeconomic issues induring , such as the Covid-19 pandemic. The Covid-19 pandemic has had a significant impact, especially in the economic field [14]. The economic implications of Covid-19, particularly in Indonesia [15,16] (Caraka et al., 2020; Suryahadi et al., 2020; World Bank, 2020), include increasing unemployment and underemployment rates, declining income levels, economic contraction, slow and uneven recovery process across sectors, including the health, economic, and education sectors. This is due to the limited sources of funding owned by the state. The government has prepared a reserve budget of USD 5.3 billion and a budget for the National Economic Recovery program of USD 37.3 billion. The funding wais used for the health sector (USD 1.0 billion), social protection (USD 2.5 billion), and support for mMicro, sSmall, and mMedium eEnterprises (USD 1.8 billioon) [17]. The sSources of funds weare derived from debt, government bonds, Sukuk, and foreign debt. The Ministry of Finance [18] Ministry of Finance (2020) released the funding components of Covid-19 originating from mMarket fFinancing, bBilateral and mMultilateral dDebts, pPrivate placement, fFinancing from oOver bBudget bBalance (SAL), and the use of gGovernment eEndowment fFunds. These components certainly have limits to meet the growing needs of handling Covid-19. Consequently, the government needs to find alternative sources of funding. Islamic social finance with a great potential can be utilized to lessen the burden of funding and accelerate the recovery from the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic.
Indonesia, as a Muslim majority country, has a high potential for Islamic sSocial fFinance. The potential for collecting zakat funds in Indonesia in 2020 wais USD 23 billion [19] (19), cash waqf wais USD 12.6 billion per year, and the overall value of waqf land is USD 140 billion [18] (20). However, the collection of zakat and waqf funds is still far from its full potential. The zakat collection in Indonesia in 2019 was only USD 0.7 billion [19] (19), while the cash waqf funds collected were only USD 0.2 billion [18] (20). One of the reasons for the vast gap between the potential realization and potential of Islamic social financeISF is a lack of optimal governance [20]. .
Furthermore, the management of ISF is facesd with severalthe problems, including of the lack of technology utilization in its management [20], k the lack of ability and competence of managers, and the lack of synergy between stakeholders [20,21], and lack of trust and public

Formatted
... literacy [20,22]. Based on a survey conducted by BAZNAS (Zakat Government Institution), nationally, the level of zakat literacy is at 66.78 %, which is in the middle category. However, for several provinces in IndonesiaDespite being the country withhaving the largest Muslim population, the literacy level for several provinces in Indonesia areis is still in the low category, with a score below 50 %. This means that literacy is not at an advanced stage, of which this includes knowledge about the existence and functions of ISF institutions, regulations, impacts, programs, and digital payments [23].
According to the law, the The governance of ISF of Islamic social finance includes aspects of collection, management, distributiondistribution, and utilization of social funds ( In addition, Fourth, Furthermore, tthe infrastructure required for management is incompleteneeded to be addressed, particularly in the field of technology [20]. This becomes an issue that deserves consideration [29]. (35). Many institutions do not have the required financial capacity to purchase the infrastructure needed for to technologysupport technologybased governance.
Problems related to the sustainability aspects of the ISF program are of concern to IRTI [29], Pitchay et al. [24], and Sukmana [26]. Based on the findings in the field Berdasarkan temuan di lapangan, mMost empowerment programs using Islamic social funds do not consider sustainability aspects and seem to end when the program ends, so that the primary goal of empowerment, namely, the transformation of mustahiq into muzakki, or mauquf ' alaihi into wakif, cannot be achieved. In addition, in the aspect of governance, Islamic social fund instruments are still partially managed. These

Formatted: English (United States)
Formatted ...   instruments have not been integrated with the State's fiscal policy [30]. (30).This is because Indonesia is based on "Pancasila", not a country withbased on Islamic law, of whichso its population consists of various beliefs and religions. There could be a sense of injustice if the government only regulates ands takes money from Muslims to help government finances. On the institutional aspect, there is a lack of coordination and synergy between stakeholders [20] (Widiastuti , Cahyono, et al., 2021). The lack of public trust in Islamic social finance managers [25] (28) needs to be an essential concern for policymakers. To overcome these problems, the solution that can be done is to formulate the integration of the Islamic social finance sector and establish a sustainable management ecosystem. To overcome these problems, the solution that can be done is to formulate the integration of the Islamic social finance sector and establish a sustainable management ecosystem.
To overcome these problems, the solution that can be done is to formulate the integration of the Islamic social finance sector and establish a sustainable management ecosystem.
The purpose of this research wais to develop a strategy for the short-and long-term integration of ISF Islamic social finance and to determine the best way to achieve that goal. This study was carried out in Indonesia, a country with a high potential for accumulating ISF Islamic social funds. In practice, however, the ISF Islamic social funds are only partially managed and have not been fully integrated. Raimi et al. [31], Jouti [32], and Shalleh et al. There has been no research that incorporates ISF Islamic sSocial fFunds that employ the two-level ANP method. The analysis of Benefit, Opportunity, Cost, and Risk (BOCR) to build the ANP framework is what makes this research unique. Several factors influenced the decision to use this method. To begin, the ANP method wais used to determine the best integration in the long-term management of ISFIslamic social finance. Second, the analysis ofze the benefits, opportunities, costs, and risks of each aspect was to produce findings that can be implemented in the short and long term. Third, this study identifieds priority solutions and strategies for achieving longterm ISF integration using the ANP BOCR method.
The findings show that the financing integration model is a priority solution in the short and long term. This demonstrates that the ISF serves several functions: Consumptive zakat is used to provide emergency assistance in the short term, productive zakat and benevolence funds are used to support economic recovery in the medium term, and waqf or sukuk are used to build long-term resilience. Furthermore, the findings of this study highlight the importance of improving the quality of HR managers through a technology-based certification and training  (particularly for data analysis, e-marketing and big database management) as the best shortand long-term strategy for implementing Islamic social finance in a sustainable manner.The findings show that the financing integration model is a priority solution in the short and long term. This demonstrates that the ISF serves several functions: Cconsumptive zakat is used to provide emergency assistance in the short term, productive zakat and benevolence funds are used to support economic recovery in the medium term, and waqf or sukuk are used to build long-term resilience. Furthermore, the findings of this study highlight the importance of improving the quality of HR managers through a technology-based certification and training (particularly for data analysis and big database management) as the best short-and long-term strategy for implementing Islamic social finance in a sustainable manner.
The findings of this study are critical for several reasons. First, solutions and strategies for the integration of sustainable ISF are expected to solve various problems of managing different instruments of ISF, resulting in the formation of a sustainable Islamic social financeISF ecosystem. Second, the findings of this study will serve as a resource for the ISF institutions in developing long-term strategic plans. Third, the results can provide a broader impact on people's well-being. Fourth, in the context of the Covid-19 pandemic, the findings can provide an overview of strategic policy steps and guidelines for seeking alternative funding sources by leveraging the potential of sustainable ISFIslamic social funds.

The cCconcept oOf Iislamic social sSocial finance fFinance aAnd iIits instruments iInstruments
Islamic sSocial fFinance is a financial system that includes traditional and contemporary ISF Islamic social finance instruments [32,[34][35][36]. (IRTI, 2020). Traditional ISF Islamic sSocial fFinance can be divided into two types: Pphilanthropy and cooperation. Zakat, infaq, sadaqah, and waqf are traditional ISF Islamic social finance instruments based on philanthropy, while . Meanwhile, the traditional Islamic social finance is based on collaboration that includes qard and kafalah are based on cooperation. Furthermore, Islamic microfinamicrofinance nce can be categorized as contemporary Islamic social financeISF. Islamic sSocial fFinance contributes to the third sector of the economy by assisting in creating more economic activities and reducing unemployment and poverty [37]. (Hamed, 2020) . Several previous studies have revealed the differences in the instruments used in Islamic sSocial fFinance, as shown in TTable 1.: Each of these instruments has different roles and functions but shares the same objective in: achieving prosperity [32] (2). The first instrument is zZakat, a mandatory economic instrument for every Muslim [40,41]  Kailani & Slama, 2020; . Zakat serves as a means for distributing wealth in the society [42] (10) from the rich to the poor to achieve socioeconomic justice, increase economic growth, and reduce inequality [43]. (11). The second instrument is infaq and sadaqah, which are the voluntary gifts by capable people to seek the pleasure of Allah [44], significantly to help the needy. (12). Zakat, infaq, and sadaqah are economic instruments that support economic growth by increasing the purchasing power of the needy [3,31]. As a third instrument, wWaqf is a social fund that plays a vital role in the Islamic framework. An asset owner donates and dedicates movable or immovable assets for the benefit of the community in perpetuity or impermanence. Waqf can be used to provide a variety of free community services, such as the construction of mosques, hospitals and healthcare centers, madrasas, education centers, and libraries [26]. (16). Waqf is a vital tool in the Islamic economic system used to meet the needs of the poorest communities and promote community economic growth [26]. (17). Furthermore, waqf, zakat, and sadaqah are instruments capable of acting as the national income and transfer payments used for redistributive purposes in an Islamic economy [6].
Islamic microfinance is the fourth instrument of ISFIslamic social finance. Islamic microfinance serves two purposes: Ssocial and commercial. As a social institution, it manages zakat, infaq, sadaqah, and waqf in accordance with the Syariah. While On the other hand, as a commercial institution, it conducts businesses and provides financing for economic development. Islamic microfinance focuses on economic development through capital assistance and the empowerment of the marginal community with no access to capital to improve their well-being [45]. (Haneef et al., 2013).

Sustainability of Iislamic sSsocial financefFinance
Sustainability refers to the capacity to operate over a long period and continuously [46]. . Sustainable growth has become a global development goal in both government and non-governmental organizations [47]. There are two paradigms in sustainability, namely, the institutionalist and welfarist [48]. (21). The institutionalist paradigm considers that financial self-sufficiency is the key to achieving sustainability. Thus, a person can be said to be sustainable if he or she achieves financial independence [48]. (21). In contrast, the welfarist paradigm considers that social functions in poverty alleviation are more important in achieving sustainability. Both paradigms are essential in the context of ISFIslamic sSocial fFinance. Financial self-sufficiency refers to an institution's ability to fund its operations independently, while also benefiting others. On the other hand, the main goals of ISF Islamic sSocial fFinance are poverty alleviation and its reachability [49][50][51]. . Three factors contribute to the sustainability of Islamic sSocial fFinance sustainability. First, the collection's sustainability is linked to the fact that funds will always be collected from the community. To ensure the longterm viability of supply funds supply, all information about zakat and its administration must be transparent and easily accessible to the public [52]. (26). Second, institutional sustainability is linked to the institution's ability and availability to carry out operational tasks [48]. (27). Third, the sustainability of distribution is linked to how the Islamic sSocial fFinance iInstitution performs its social and intermediary functions to improve welfare and achieve broader benefits [50]. In practice, the empowerment programs of ISF Islamic sSocial fFinance institutions have not been able to transform the poor into prosperous. Furthermore, many of these programs come to an end after a certain period and do not track whether the poor arehave truly become selfsufficient and prosperous. Several factors contribute to the unsustainable nature of ISF Islamic sSocial fFinance institutions' empowerment projects [20]. To begin, massive sums of money are required to provide effective and optimal empowerment. (Widiastuti et al., 2018). Second, qualified human resources with leadership qualities are needed [53].

Issues with Iislamic sSsocial finance fFinance integrationiIntegration
In order to achieve optimal management, ISF Islamic sSocial fFinance must overcome several challenges. A lack of motivation among beneficiaries to develop, a lack of synergy and coordination among stakeholders, a lack of human resources capabilities and quantity to manages Islamic social finance, a lack of ability to optimize technology, regulations that are still voluntary, and a lack of awareness and trust of muzakki in Islamic sSocial fFinance institutions are among the problems encountered by Islamic sSocial fFinance [20,[24][25][26]55]  Given the obstacles that result in a substantial gap between the potential and actualization of Islamic social finance management, it is vital to integrate Islamic Social Finance instruments on a continuous basis to attain an optimum level of management.Given the challenges which consequently create a significant gap between the potential and actualization of Islamic social finance management and accounting for the enormous potential of Islamic social finance, it is necessary to integrate Islamic Social Finance instruments on an ongoing basis to achieve optimum level of management.

Integration model of Iislamic social finance
Integration refers to the process of blending into a single unit, thus, integration in ISF Islamic social finance combines funds management, institutions, governance, functions, etc. According to Balassa [57], integration offers various advantages. First, integration allows for the mobility of production elements, which has a positive impact on enhancing welfare. Second, integration has the ability to reduces costs, resulting in an increase in output. Third, integration promotes job specialization. Fourth, integrationthe createsion aof welfare through policy harmonization. Fifth, integration can increase technology adoption. Furthermore, integration has a favorable impact on the socio-economic aspects of the community, including: (1) Iimproving sustainability performance [58], ,(2) enhancing economic growth [59], ,and (3)

Research method and analysis approach
The Analytical Network Process (ANP) method wais used in this qualitative study, along with the analysis of Benefit, Opportunity, Cost, and Risk (BOCR). This two-levels ANP method has the characteristics of mathematically examined conditions and inputs obtained based on several criteriaconstructs,, allowing it to aid the decision-making from various options and complex data [62]. (43). The ANP method approach was chosen because ISF Islamic social funds include various instruments, each with its own set of characteristics and issues, both Formatted ...

Formatted
...  tangible and intangible. In this study, the ANP approach wais the best choice for producing strategic decisions [63]. Meanwhile, the BOCR analysis was selected for a variety of reasons,. tTo begin, every decision has both positive and negative consequences, which must be considered when determining priority decisions (44). Second, the BOCR approach wais used to make decisions that can be implemented in the short and long terms. The ANP BOCR method prioritizes solutions and strategies to develop a sustainable ISF Islamic social finance integration model. The ANP method of research has three phases, which are depicted in Figureure 1 [64]. below (45).:

Figure 1. ANP BOCR Research Stage
Source: Ascarya [64] (45) First, the decomposition phase seeks sought to construct and validate the ANP model through fFocus gGroup dDiscussions and in-depth interviews with experts in ISF Islamic social finance from among academics, practitioners, associations, regulators, and community leaders. In addition, a A lLliterature review was conducted as part of this study to strengthen the ANP model that was developed. A literature review analysis wais used to collect problems, solutions, and strategies discovered and analyzed by previous researchers to integrate sustainable ISF. In addition, the literature review analysis was used to validate the findings from the focus groups discussion and in-depth interviews.   Three Ffocus Ggroup Ddiscussions (FGDs) were held. The first and second FGDs were held with experts to identify aspects, solutions, and strategies for integrating sustainable ISF and identify benefits, opportunities, costs, and risks to determine the short-term and long-term analyses. The model developed through FGD 1 and 2 was then strengthened through in-depth interviews and literature reviews. Following that, the third FGD validated the constructed ANP model. The second was the pairwise comparison phase to design a questionnaire in the form of a pairwise comparison to determine and analyze aspects, solutions, and priority strategies in integrating sustainable ISF. The questionnaire that the respondents had answered were used for the next phase. The third was the data analysis phase, which aimed to calculate the priority value of each aspect, solution, and strategy formulated using the Microsoft Excel and Super Decision software. The use of the ANP method with the BOCR approach made it possible to produce realistic and net values. The net value/additive negative describes alternative options that are more profitable or ideal to be prioritized in the long term, while realistic/multiplicative value represents more favorable outcomes for short-term decisionsThree focus group discussions were held. The first and second Ffocus Ggroup Ddiscussions (FGDs) were held with experts to identify aspects, solutions, and strategies for integrating sustainable Islamic social finance and identify benefits, opportunities, costs, and risks to determine the short-term and long-term analyseis. The model developed through FGD 1 and 2 was then strengthened through in-depth interviews and literature reviews. Following that, the third FGD validateds the constructed ANP model. The sSecond was, the pairwise comparison phase to design a questionnaire in the form of a pairwise comparison to determine and analyze aspects, solutions, and priority strategies in integrating sustainable Islamic social finance. The questionnaire that the respondents hadve answered will bewere used for the next phase. The third wais the data analysis phase, which aimeds to calculate the priority value of each aspect, solution, and strategy formulated using the Microsoft Excel and Super Decision software. The use of the ANP method with the BOCR approach madkes it possible to produce realistic and net values. The net value/additive negative describes alternative options that are more profitable or ideal to be prioritized in the long term, while realistic/multiplicative value represents more favorable outcomes for short-term decisions [63,65]  B or b stands for Benefit, O or o stand for Opportunity, C or c stands for cost, R or r stands for Risk. After the analysis phase, the next step wais to validate the results with various ISFIslamic sSocial fFinance experts to strengthen the integration model that will be built.

Data and research samples
The data used weare primary data obtained through focus groups, in-depth interviews, and ANP questionnaires filled out by the respondents. The data sources gathered were from 13 experts fromamong academics, practitioners, associations, regulators, and community leaders.
In ANP research, the number of respondents is not a critical the most important requirement for research validation [66] (Firmansyah and & Sukmana, 2014), but rather their expertise iss. Each expert completed the questionnaire consciously and in a mentally healthy state. The participants weare required to fill in a specific consent form before hand to ensure that they weare not subject to any pressure from any party to participate in the interviews. The research team guaranteeds the confidentiality of the experts' data and answers responses and is fully responsible for all applicable laws. Applicable laws will account for the disclosure of confidential data and experts' responses.
In The purposive sampling technique aims to select respondents according to the criteria required in the ANP method. For this study, the selected respondents must have the following criteria: (1) Rrespondents are experts in the field of ISF Islamic social finance from among academics, practitioners, associations, regulators, and community leaders,; (2) have more than two journal publications in the field of ISF Islamic social finance for academic representatives,; and (3) for representatives of regulator, practitioners, and associations, they should hold an important position and bear a great responsibility in the management of ISF Islamic social finance in their respective institutions. The research team will contacted the prospective (representative) respondents by phone and email before conducting the interviews to inquire about their willingness to complete the questionnaire. There weare two options for completing the questionnaire: Oonline or offline. In the case whereFor the respondents who opted to complete the questionnaire offline, the research team will attended to them, while adhering to a strict health protocol, by still maintaining a safe distance and wearing a mask. For respondents who opted to fill out questionnaires via teleconference zoom, they were accompanied by three team members with each job desk either as: a moderator, a note-taker, and or a backup. The list of respondents in this study is shown in Table 2.:   Theis study's questionnaire of the study is in the form of a pairwise comparison of the benefits, opportunities, costs, and risks of related aspects in integrating sustainable ISFIslamic social finance. Governance, sustainable financing, institutions, regulations, technology, and human resources are among the issues at stake in integrating the instruments of ISFIslamic social finance. The questionnaire also develops comprises various solutions and strategies to achieve the research objectives. The pairwise comparison assessment in the questionnaire is rated on a scale of 1-9, where 1 (one) means not important/needed/influential and 9 (nine) means absolutely important/needed/influential.

Result
This study aimeds to integrate sustainable ISF by building solutions and priority strategies in the short and long term. Before developing solutions and strategies, identification of important aspects wais carried out to provide a comprehensive analysis of the most appropriate priority solutions and strategies in integrating sustainable ISF.

Priority aspect
Human resources, regulation, technology, sustainable financing, governance, and institutions are six aspects related to the integration of sustainable ISFIslamic social finance, according to the FGD and in-depth interviews. Table 3 shows the aspects with the highest priority based on the ANP data processing.         The data processing results show that human resource is the highest priority aspect in ISF Islamic social finance institutions, with a value of 0.97181. HThe human resource refers tois all people/staff/employees who participate in the management of ISF [20]. Human resources play a crucial role in Islamic Social Finance management. With a value of 0.8689, the regulation comes in as the second priority. Regulations are all rules put in place to provide legal guidance and support for the management and development of ISF Islamic sSocial fFinance [67]. With a value of 0.7682, the third priority aspect is the use of technology, while sustainable financing comes in the following priority order with a value of 0.7645. Sustainable funding is associated with business development and achieving financial independence using Islamic social funds [68]. Governance is thea fifth priority aspect with a value of 0.7152. The collection, distribution, and utilization process in ISF Islamic social finance are governed by transparency, accountability, responsibility, independence, and fairness [69]. The institutional aspect comes as the least priority, with a score of 0.6767. The institutional aspect relates to the structure and coordination system. In Indonesia, ISF institutions can take the form of government and private legal entities [70]. For zakat management, it can be in the legal entity can take in the form of of the Amil Zakat Institution (LAZ) and the National Amil Zakat Agency (BAZNAS), while. For the management of waqf in the form of a Nazir is the legal entity for the management of waqf..

Priority solution in integrating sustainable Iislamic social finance
There are eight solutions to integrate sustainable ISF Islamic social finance based on the findings of the focus group, in-depth interviews, and literature review.  Islamic social finance institutions based on capacity building and role division. This type of integration is dependent on the specialization of each institution and community, includesing vertical and horizontal integrations [70]. This type of integration is dependent on the specialization of each institution and community.The vVertical integration is achieved through a collaboration between ISF institutions and the government. The government can collaborates by providing a database of people who are eligible to receive Islamic social finance funds. The government also provides rules and guidance for the management of ISF. Meanwhile, a horizontal integration is takingis conducted place between ISF management institutions, where Islamic social financedifferent institutions collaborate to carry out joint social programs [32]. FurthermoreIn addition, a horizontal integration is also carried out with academics and associations for future management development of the ISF [20]. Some organizations concentrate on the health sector, while others concentrate on economic empowerment and education. As a result, combining institutions based on their specialization may be the best option for achieving the research objective. The fFifth (SL.5) is (SL.5) establishing an integrated national data center for all ISF Islamic social finance instruments; the data that must be integrated include financial statements, donor funds, beneficiary data, and other relevant information. The sSixth is (SL.6) includes an integration based on regional clusters with a solid authority. This integration may concentrate on integrating Islamic social finance institutions into geographical groups. The seventh solution (SL.7) incorporates integrating ISF Islamic social finance through the passage of new laws and regulations. Each instrument of ISFIslamic social finance, currently, has its own set of rules and regulations. The eighth solution is (SL.8) is an integration based on ISF Islamic social finance management clusters, such as zakat Amils joining other zakat institutions and waqf manager joining other waqf institutions. Table 4 shows the ANP result of solution and the order of priority solutions in the short term, long term, and based on experts' agreement The formulated solution wais then processed using the ANP BOCR to determine the priority order of solutions. Short term solution considers the marginal cost of the benefits obtained. WhileOon the contrary, At the same time, in the long term, the analysis is a priority is achieved when the total number of benefits and opportunities are can be obtained after by reducing the total cost and risk [63,65]. On the other hand, an expert judgment does not consider the benefits, opportunity, cost, and risk aspects of each solution formulated in this study. Table 4 shows the order of priority solutions in the short term, long term, and based on experts' agreement , while Table 5 summarizes the results of data processing. as follows: According to the data processing results, the first and second priorities in the short and longterm are in the same order. The solutions that will be implemented first and foremost in the short and long term are financial integration in providing funding to beneficiaries and integration of Islamic social finance with the state fiscal policy. According to expert judgment, integrating national data centers is the highest priority solution, with financial integration in providing funding to beneficiaries coming in second.

Priority strategies in integrating sustainable Iislamic social finance
There are nine strategies to integrate sustainable ISF Islamic social finance based on the findings of the FGD, in-depth interviews, and literature review. The ANP results and order of priority strategies is shown in Table 6, which displays the shortterm, long-term priority solutions, and expert judgment. After the solution has been developing the solutioned, a strategy must be developed. Strategies are employed to aid in the achievement of solutions, and thus, the integration of ISF will be realized. The order of priority strategies is shown in Ttable 6, which displays the short-term, long-term priority solutions, and expert judgment. The strategies are summarized in Ttable 7. as follows: Source: Author's compilation (2021) The results show that the short and long-term strategies are in the same order. Improving the quality of human resources, establishing real-time database integration and reporting, and optimizing the use of digital technology, become the priority strategies. However, the expert judgment put considers the optimization use of digital technology to be the priority strategy.

Priority solution iIn developing aA sustainable Iislamic social finance integration model
Financial integration in providing financing to beneficiaries is a high-priority solution that can be implemented in the short and long term. Further, this solution is very consistent with the sustainability paradigm, where the funding provided will broaden the range of benefits, and , ultimately, creates financial independence for the beneficiaries, as stated by Haneef et al.  [73] shows that by distributing zakat, the time taken by the poor to exit poverty is faster (3.3 years) than without zakat (6.6 years). In addition, a study conducted by Widiastuti et al. [3] which analyzeds financing programs carried out by the Lembaga Islamic social finance sepertiISF institutions, including Yatim Mandiri, Dompet Dhuafa, Inisiatif Zakat Indonesia, Nurul Hayat, YDSF, and Dompet Amanah Umat, and found that they have a significant impact on increasing the on welfare of the poor. The distribution aspect, particularly productive distribution, holds the key to success in ISF integration in transforming the poor into the richcapables [69]. A fFinancial integration through ISF instruments, such as zakat and waqf, will increase production factors. In this case, financing will be more effective due to an increase in the amount of funds obtained by the poor to achieve welfare. This is consistent with the economic integration theory advanceddiscussed by Balassa [57]. This also supports Sanyinna and Omar [74] Hamed's (2020) claim that Islamic financing benefits small businesses by maximizing Islamic social financial instruments (zakat, infaq, sadaqah, and waqf) as the best strategy for improving the recipients' quality of life. The financing provided through integrating Islamic social finance instruments has a cheap cost of the fund, and; thus, it ensures the beneficiaries' welfare. Furthermore, the integration of financing demonstrates that Islamic social fund instruments serve multiple purposes: Cconsumptive zakat is used to provide an emergency assistance in the short term, while productive zakat and benevolence funds are used to support economic recovery in the medium term, and waqf or Sukuk are used to build long-term resilience. The financial integration of Islamic social fund finance instruments has also occurred in several institutions, although only on a micro-scale. Several institutions in Indonesia have worked to integrate zakat and waqf Formatted Table  ...

Formatted
...  This priority, however, differs from expert opinion, which emphasizes the importance of integrating nationally centralized data, such as database on donors, beneficiaries, and financial reports, and so on. According to Afriadi and Sanrego [54] and Hudaefi et al. [75] [50,68,69], the formation of national-centered data is critical for optimizing the integration and management of ISF Islamic social finance. The integration of beneficiary-related information is crucial for detecting data on beneficiary development and preventing overlapping distributions. Since ISF Islamic social funds are still managed in a fragmented manner (partially), no single platform currently integrates the data from all instruments of ISF Islamic social finance in Indonesia. As the latest development, a data integration platform, has been established in the zakat sector. BAZNAS, an Indonesian zakat institution and regulator, released SIMBA (BAZNAS Information Management System), an integrated platform for zakat database management from all BAZNAS and LAZNAS across Indonesia. This platform only integrates the data from national zakat collections. As a result, establishing a central platform capable of integrating data on all Islamic social financiale instruments is critical.
Financial integration and integration of national data centers are interrelated. This is so since funding distribution necessitates specific data to ensure the long-term viability of the funds provided. Data integration is needed to reduce the potential risk and realize the collection of distributed financings so that the supply of funds will be guaranteed. Further, the integration of beneficiary data is needed to ensure the depth of the reach of benefits and the creation of financial independence, and; thus, sustainability will be achieved. On another side, financial integration remains a short-and long-term priority because it is directly related to the primary goal of Islamic social finance, which is to create prosperity by improving the business and economic capacity of beneficiaries. As one of the priority solutions in this research, the regulator must provide a legal environment to accommodate all changes and developments in the management of Islamic sSocial fFinance. First, the government must revise the law to accommodate the rapid growth of Islamic social finance instruments [76] . Second, the government must socialize the revised laws and regulations to all stakeholders, and make the law more socially acceptable [20,77]. Third, encourage ISF management institutions to implement the law by offering rewards or incentives that the Institution can use, such as free training and, accompaniment [20]. and s . The difference in priorities between expert judgments and short/long term orientations occurs because of technology investment, which is considered a long-term investment, necessitates a significant funding source, which some zakat institutions may not afford [20]. . Optimizing the use of technology, which requires a large amount of investment, is a challenge for Islamic social finance institutions, particularly in Indonesia. This is due to the fact that the operational costs incurred by ISF Islamic social fund institutions are determined by the amount of funds that can be raised. Meanwhile, there is a significant gap between the realization and potential of ISFIslamic social funds. As a result, institutions prefer to improve competencies and capabilities of human Formatted ...

Formatted
...  resources, relevant to their respective fields of work compared to improving technological features. This is also consistent with the aspects of BOCR addressed in this study. The cost of optimizing technology use is 0.0537, higher than the cost of improving the quality of human resources, which is around 0.0466. Costs associated with technology investments include acquiring digital channels, website management, social media, purchase of computers, and maintenance cost, etc.
Furthermore, when determining priority strategies in the short and long term, experts also consider the risks exposed. The risk of optimizing the use of technology is high (0.0632), with the benefits obtained are also higher (0.0555). Meanwhile, the threat from the institution's strategy to improve the quality of human resources is lower at 0.0459. Cybercrime is one of the risks of optimizing the use of technology in ISF Islamic social finance [ . Improving the quality of human resources is the foundation for the long-term integration of ISFIslamic social finance, while technology facilitates an optimal ISF Islamic social finance management.
Finally, in order to integrate sustainable ISFIslamic social finance, stakeholders must prioritize solutions and strategies, by taking into accountconsidering the benefits, opportunities, costs, and risks (BOCR) of each priority solution and strategy. Improving the quality of human resources and optimizing the use of digital technology are two strategies that must be implemented immediately. Based on the short-and long-term analysis and expert consensus, the two strategies are given the highest priority.

Managerial rRelevancy
This study has several implications for stakeholders. The findings of this study emphasize solutions and priority strategies for integrating ISFIslamic social finance, with Islamic social finance institutions playing a critical role in providing certification and training to improve the quality of human resources. Each training activity and accreditation must be given in accordance with the employee's field of work. Technology optimization, such as big data management, data security, e-marketing, and others, are examples of certification and training that must be provided. Human resource quality must be directed atto obtain management and technical skills. Managers are encouraged to have managerial skills, such as making strategic decisions, forecasting, and imposing rewards and punishments. Staff are encouraged to learn  technical skills, such as collection program operation, mustahik guidance, reporting, and administration, and so on.
The government, as a regulator, must assist Islamic philanthropic social finance institutions in providing facilities or infrastructure to improve the quality of human resource managers, such as free training and certification for managers. Further, no law or regulation has required ISF Islamic sSocial fFinance managers to have standardized or specific competencies. As a result, one form of input for the revision of the law and regulation requires all ISF Islamic sSocial fFinance managers to have specific competencies in managing Islamic philanthropic social finance institutions so that these institutions can be managed more professionally.
This study also emphasizes the significance of financial integration and data integration on the national scale. Associations involved in Islamic philanthropy social finance can use the research findings to establish strategic planning on integrating ISFIslamic sSocial fFinance instruments. From an academic standpoint, the results of this study develop the previous studies on the integration of the ISF Islamic sSocial fFinance model, which were conducted without using specific mathematical methods. This study useds a systematic approach to create an ideal integration model that can be of priorities both in the short and long term, while also taking the aspect of BOCR into account.

Conclusion
This research used thes ANP BOCR to develop priority solutions and strategies to integrate Islamic social finance based on expert agreement, short-term and long-term analysis. The aspect of human resources, regulation, and technologyical use become the highest aspect to be considered in achieving the research objective. Priority solutions in the short and long terms have the same order of priorities. Financial integration in providing funding to beneficiaries and integration with the state fiscal policy is the first and second priority solution. Meanwhile, integration through a non-formal coordination between institutions is the third priority solution in the long term. Besides, integrating national data centers has been the third priority solution for a long time term and the highest solution based on expert judgments. In essence, the resulting priority solutions relate to priority aspects of include financing, regulation, and technology.
As a strategy, improving the quality of hHuman rResources, establishing real-time information through database integration and reporting, and optimizing digital technology are three priority strategies that can be implemented in the short and long term. Furthermore, the experts mentioned the need for coordination and synergy between stakeholders in integrating sustainable Islamic social finance. To successfully incorporate Islamic social finance and ensure sustainability, stakeholders are encouraged to implement the research results (solutions and strategiesy).  This questionnaire aims to develop solutions and strategies to build a sustainable Islamic Social Finance integration model by considering the benefits, opportunity costs and risks (BOCR) of the model built. This questionnaire aims to collect primary data in order to develop the Analytical Network Process model. It is hoped that in this study the strategy can be developed using the Analytical Network Process.

Limitation and Study fFuture rResearchForward
This questionnaire is the primary data collection stage for the research "Sustainable Islamic Social Finance Model: Strategic Solution in Countering Adverse Impacts of Social Economy of The Covid-19 Using Analytical Network Process Benefit Opportunities Cost Risk. This questionnaire is designed to determine the personal assessment of key informants, which include practitioners, experts/experts, government representatives, academics, community leaders, and associations. There is no right or wrong answer, but this assessment aims to compare the level of importance or priority of each attribute to a problem. The rating scale will be explained as follows:     a. There is mismanagement in the implementation of the functions of Islamic social financial institutions b. Islamic social finance institutions have not adopted all the principles in governance c. There is potential for miscommunication both internally and externally by Islamic social financial institutions d. Mis-Coordination related to the division of tasks and roles e. Differences in work patterns and culture between institutions f. Incompatibilities of the supervisory board g. Supervision is not carried out thoroughly h. Reports that are not representative and less accurate i. There is potential for non-compliance with regulations, both formal rules and sharia rules in Islamic social finance governance j. The achievement of several SDGs points is contradictory to the essence of the function of Islamic social finance institutions k. The 17 goals in the SDGs are not all relevant to the ZISWAF goals 2. The following are several risks from the sustainable financing aspect in the integration of Islamic Social Finance, how influential are the risks below in integrating Islamic Social Finance? a. There is liquidity risk for financial institutions  b. The absence of guarantees creates a moral hazard problem c. Lack of motivation of recipients of Islamic social finance to develop d. Failure in carrying out financing e. Time is needed in conditioning the synchronization between ziswaf institutions and the government regarding the legality of the law f. Literacy related to Islamic social funds is still far from expected g. High refusal to use waqf funds to lend 3. The following are several risks from the institutional aspect in integrating Islamic Social Finance; how influential are the risks below in integrating Islamic Social Finance? a. The institutional model is not flexible in accommodating problems b. Institutional fund management will limit the space for innovation.
4. The following are several risks from the HR aspect in institutions in the integration of Islamic Social Finance, how influential are the risks below in the integration of Islamic Social Finance? a. High employee turnover rate b. The profession of nazhir and/or amil is not considered as the primary profession c. Increasing digitalization will replace the role and number of HR 5. The following are several risks from regulatory aspects in integrating Islamic Social Finance; how influential are the risks below in the integration of Islamic Social Finance? a. There are no mandatory rules b. There is a period for regulatory amendments, so regulations are less flexible in responding to current conditions c. There are political challenges in strengthening regulations d. Change of leader replaces policy direction e. Conflicts of interest that arise between policymakers 6. The following are several risks from using technology in the integration of Islamic Social Finance; how influential are the risks below in the integration of Islamic Social Finance? a. There is a crime in the implementation of technology b. There is a potential for non-fulfillment of sharia principles with the use of technology

SECTION 3: SOLUTION AND STRATEGIES IN INTEGRATING ISLAMIC SOCIAL FINANCE
1. The following are several solutions in integrating Islamic Social Finance; how important are the solutions below in the integration of Islamic Social Finance? a. Financial integration in providing funding to beneficiaries through the distribution of zakat, waqf, and Islamic microfinance based on the beneficiaries' economic circumstances and capabilities b. Integrating ISF with state fiscal instruments, which is supported by existing regulations c. Integration through non-formal coordination between ISF institutions d. Integration among Islamic social finance institutions based on capacity building and role division e. Establishing an integrated national data center for all ISF instruments f. Integration based on regional clusters with a solid authority g. Integrating ISF through the passage of new laws and regulations h. Integration based on ISF management clusters, such as zakat Amils joining other zakat institutions and waqf manager joining other waqf institutions